This Independence Day ... my thoughts.
Resolve to be free, and India will be free as a consequence. It doesn’t work the other way round.
This Independence Day …
“We accept that, other than the majoritarian male, everyone else in India has to be ideal, and an idol, to be worthy of becoming an offspring of India.”
— Ranjona Banerjee. [@ranjona]
On this Independence Day, we find ourselves living in the epoch of the Indian Majoritarian Male, [IMM], ably lead by their 56” iconic figure, Shri Narendra Modi. That his deification necessarily requires the effacement, nay erasure, of Jashdoaben, should not surprise us. It is an intrinsic part of the new era that is creeping up upon us.
Pegasus was the proverbial tip of the iceberg, in the vast apparatus of the IMM, as he struggles to assert majoritarian control over a rapidly atomizing society, wherein he finds himself reduced from the Patriarch to a plebeian, as technology transforms reality, & vaults it into a altogether new dimension.
Technology, and knowledge, are the great disruptor, and the equalizer. With their carefully nurtured monopoly on knowledge in tatters, the IMM have reverted to authoritarianism, backed by muscle and numbers, to turn the clock back. The attempt is doomed to failure, but that doesn’t mean its potential for harm is limited. In so much as it’s a desperate act to assert control over the uncontrollable, its potential for devastation is that much greater.
The majoritarian male is a relic of the industrial era. This was an age in which we learned how to use division of labour, to enable mass production of goods and services, at a vastly reduced costs. The technologies of cheap mass-produced goods, expanded markets, sucked in new consumers, creating a virtuous cycle of progress, that brought unprecedented prosperity to the doorsteps of the multitudes. What was once the luxury of Pharaohs, became the platter of plebeians, come breakfast time.
Organizing mass production using division of labour necessarily means regimentation. We marched off the young to factories called schools, where we got them accustomed to sitting on desks for hours at a stretch, mindlessly absorbing the three Rs required to plug them into factories. We promised them jobs, and if they worked hard at the machines provide, a decent living, a small family, and a dwelling of their own. That is the basic building block of all modern societies; Capitalistic, or otherwise.
Performance versus promise varies sharply from nation to nation, in proportion to the honesty of elites. Those with relatively honest elites prospered; those rapacious, managed to impoverish their masses even amidst the plentitude.
The world already produces more food, clothing, shelter - and indeed any other everyday good that we can think of - than the 7 billion of us living on the planet can consume.
That millions still go hungry, have no shirt on their backs, or live in hovels of plastic sheets, is not because humanity lacks the capacity, or the wealth, to provide them with the necessities, but because we cannot find a way to plug them into the vast matrix of income producing activities, that would give them access to a livelihood.
The age of plentitude has arrived. What we lack is an equitable means of sharing it out among ourselves.
As complex automated processing plants, and robots, replace the Alpha Males [AM] in workshops, the AM finds himself diminished. The Indian AM is hit with double whammy. There is acute sense of failure about having missed the global bus to industrialization. With global productive capacities already in excess of demand, the future in manufacturing is bleak.
The skills set required to cater to highly atomized and personalized emerging economies, are neither in place, nor a part of the school curriculum.
The gig economy, where you rotate among three or four hustles, to earn a livelihood, can never be a part of your IMM’s toolkit. He still hankers after a highly structured 9 to 5 job, where application of mind, initiative, entrepreneurial skills are least necessary. He wants guaranteed outcomes, certainty, and old privilege, where the gig economy offers uncertainty, higher risks and unprecedented change. He is frightened out of his wits, ready to lash out at anything that threatens the orderly life he has in mind.
It this mindless Borg that has been mobilized, empowered, and let loose on the streets, in pursuit of a dream that is well past its time. Too much water has flown down the Ganges for the past to return for him.
On this Independence Day, it is worthwhile to ponder what Professor Deborah Tenner meant when she said:
“To survive in the world, we have to act in concert with others, but to survive as ourselves, rather than simply as cogs in a wheel, we have to act alone.”
Freedom works in two realms; sometime in tandem, at other times asynchronously. The dystopia that is upon us can’t be wished away. But it exists, if at all, in the domain of collective action, where mindless emotive frenzy, whipped up by demented demagogues, has replaced reason. They have their plans, we should have our own.
The more important freedoms are in the domain of personal action, where freedom is limited only by your creativity. The same technologies that bring us dirt cheap mass communication, pervasive surveillance, fake news and propaganda factories, and the toolkits to manipulate our minds, also bring empowerment to individuals, access to education and knowledge, the power to collaborate cheaply with others like us, and to build networks to distribute goods and services, at tiny, atomized scale, in intensely local communities.
The new gig economy is not limiting. It has at once lowered the barriers to entrepreneurial activities that were once reserved for the lucky few. If it feels strange, it is only because most of us have never been to taught to think, feel, and work as entrepreneurs. Yet, entrepreneur skills are innate to every human. It is an epoch in which you can survive, thrive, and prosper, only by unleashing your innate ingenuity and enterprise.
The gig economy is for everyone. The most advantaged are women because they have less to unlearn than men; and even less to learn. We have always lived, and survived, by our wits, in the most oppressive of patriarchies. We, more than men, know how to build intimate networks in intensely local neighborhoods. We will be the new entrepreneurs and winners in the gig economy, working with our wits, using our innate creativity.
The IMM senses this. If anybody can defeat the Majoritarian Male patriarch, even in the collective domain, it is women. In many parts of the world, not excluding the US, but also such unlikely places as UAE or Saudi Arabia, women graduating out of colleges outnumber men. In neighboring Pakistan, they have to reserve seats for men in medical colleges in order for them to enter college at all. We are the future.
In our bones we know freedom has to be won everyday. Nobody gives it to us. Freedom for many a woman comes from the ability to pay bills, independently of the spouse. We are trained for submissiveness and dependency, but despite that, many of us today pay our own bills. And are proud of it.
Let the Alpha male dominate the streets.
Put your head down and go to work. The amazing number of intensely localized hustles you can run is mind boggling. Explore the web. Pinterest is a good place to begin to discover how people hustle every thing for hair styling to digital stationary, pickles to pancakes, mirchi to masala .. the very spice of lives - to earn livelihoods that can often be scaled up big time. There is plenty to do, from helping children with school, to caring for the aged, from giving lessons in pottery making, to sharing insights on why prime numbers are so sparse. Innovation is the key. Access to knowledge is virtually free. It is a matter of educating yourself, and then letting your creativity run wild. That is where the future is. Unleash your curiosity, creativity, and enterprise.
When you can pay your bills, Patriarchy for the most part shrinks, shrivels, curling up like the now extinct carbon paper, and hurriedly scuttles to get out of your way. That is real freedom, and it can only be earned.
Rest assured when we do that in numbers, the majoritarian male, always a paper tiger, will slink off into obscurity from our streets, and our homes. Resolve to be free, and India will be free a consequence. It doesn’t work the other wary round. You know that.
Brilliant essay, where every sentence is a quote. There are two powers in the world; one is the sword and the other is the pen. There is a great competition and rivalry between the two. There is a third power stronger than both, that of the women.
Please read.
Beautifully written. I sincerely hope that this happens. Thanks once again mam.